coconutsugar.pro

ICUMSA and Coconut Sugar: Why the Grade Doesn't Apply

Direct answer

I was offered ICUMSA 45 coconut sugar. What does that mean?

ICUMSA 45 is a trade grade for white sugar, not a colour on its own. The benchmark white sugar futures contract delivers white beet, cane crystal or refined sugar whose colour is at most 45 ICUMSA units (ICE Futures Europe, White Sugar Futures, as read 5 November 2026). Coconut sugar is made from coconut palm sap, so the grade cannot describe it.

What describes it instead is a colour stated in words, with moisture, ash, sucrose and particle size. This page sets out what ICUMSA itself publishes, so the difference between a colour measurement and a grade is checkable. It belongs to the coconut sugar trade glossary.

1. What ICUMSA publishes

ICUMSA, the International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis, describes itself as “the only international organisation concerned solely with analytical methods for the sugar industry” (ICUMSA, About ICUMSA, as read 5 November 2026). Its subject is how to measure a sugar, not what a sugar must measure to be traded.

Its Methods Book is meant for methods “specific for and clear application within the sugar industry”, and leaves out the “analysis of products or materials not specific for the sugar industry” (ICUMSA, Scope of ICUMSA Methods Book, as read 5 November 2026). The full method texts are sold; what is free, and what this page relies on, is each method’s title and scope abstract.

2. ICUMSA’s colour methods and their stated scope

ICUMSA lists four methods for colour in solution. Each measures the absorbance of a filtered sugar solution at 420 nm.

MethodTitle as ICUMSA lists itScope ICUMSA states
GS1-7 (2024)Colour in Solution of Sugars and Syrups with more than 250 and less than 16,000 ICUMSA® Units and pH Adjustment with HCl/NaOH – OfficialRaw sugars, higher colour plantation white sugars, partially refined sugars, brown sugars and coloured sugar syrups
GS2-9 (2024)Colour in Solution of Sugars with more than 20 and less than 600 ICUMSA® Units and pH Adjustment with TEA/HCl Buffer – Accepted“all crystalline and powdered sugars” up to 600 units
GS2-10 (2024)Colour in Solution of Sugars, Liquid Sugar and Syrups with less than 50 ICUMSA® Units and with no pH Adjustment – OfficialWhite sugars and very pure syrups up to 50 units
GS9-8 (2026)Colour in Solution of Sugars with more than 10 and less than 16,000 ICUMSA® Units and pH Adjustment with MOPS Buffer – Official (Reference)Raw, affined raw, white and plantation white sugar; a filtered solution must be preparable

Sources for the four rows: (ICUMSA, Method GS1-7 (2024), as read 5 November 2026); (ICUMSA, Method GS2-9 (2024), as read 5 November 2026); (ICUMSA, Method GS2-10 (2024), as read 5 November 2026); (ICUMSA, Method GS9-8 (2026), as read 5 November 2026). None of the four names coconut or palm sugar.

3. A colour measurement is not a trade grade

Read literally, one method could reach coconut sugar. GS2-9 is scoped to “all crystalline and powdered sugars” up to 600 units, so a laboratory could run it on a coconut sugar solution that filters and reads within that range (ICUMSA, Method GS2-9 (2024), as read 5 November 2026). The result would be a colour number for that sample.

A grade is something else. In trade, “ICUMSA 45” is the quality clause of a white sugar contract (ICE Futures Europe, White Sugar Futures, as read 5 November 2026): the deliverable sugar is “White beet, cane crystal sugar or refined sugar”, with a minimum polarisation, a maximum moisture, and “colour of a maximum of 45 units ICUMSA attenuation index”. The grade names the sugar and sets three limits. A colour reading on coconut sugar meets none of that definition, whatever it reads.

ICUMSA itself is still working out where its colour methods apply among cane specialities. In 2023 it recommended verifying whether its method GS1/3-7 (2011) applies to “the brown sugar specialties Demerara and Muscovado” (ICUMSA, Recommendations 2023, as read 5 November 2026), and in 2025 that GS9-8 be evaluated for products above 16,000 units, “such as Muscovado sugars” (ICUMSA, Recommendations 2025, as read 5 November 2026). Neither session’s recommendations name palm or coconut sugar.

4. When a seller offers ICUMSA 45 coconut sugar

The offer pairs a grade defined for white beet or cane sugar with a sugar made from coconut sap. It can be read three ways, and each reading has a question that settles it.

The buyer question, answered

If the offer meansAsk the seller
White sugar, under a coconut sugar nameWhich sugar is it, made from which plant?
A colour reading taken on coconut sugarWhich ICUMSA method, number and year; what reading; on which lot? A reading is not the grade, which also sets polarisation and moisture
A line carried over from a refined-sugar templateCan you quote colour, moisture, ash, sucrose and particle size instead?

None of the three answers turns coconut sugar into ICUMSA 45 sugar. In the third case, the specification below replaces the line.

5. What to specify instead

Our coconut sugar is specified by these physical lines, with colour stated in words. ICUMSA is not a line on our specification. Limits dated .

ParameterSpecification limit
Moisture< 3.0%
Ashmax 2.0%
Sucrose85.0–90.0%
Reducing sugars5.0–10.0%
Water-insoluble mattermax 0.2%
Colourlight brown to medium golden brown
Particle size> 95% passing mesh 30 (granulated) / mesh 50 (powder)

The same limits, with metal and micro-organism limits, are set out on conventional (natural) granulated coconut sugar, and what each line looks like on a Certificate of Analysis is in how to read a coconut sugar COA.

6. Where the ICUMSA line comes from

ICE describes its White Sugar futures contract as “the global benchmark for the pricing of physical white sugar” (ICE Futures Europe, White Sugar Futures, as read 5 November 2026), and ICUMSA 45 is that contract’s colour clause. If a specification template written for white sugar is reused for coconut sugar, the ICUMSA clause comes with it; replacing it with the lines above fixes the template.

ICUMSA questions

Does ICUMSA publish a colour method for coconut sugar?

None of its four colour-in-solution methods names coconut or palm sugar in its published scope, and its 2023 and 2025 session recommendations name neither. One method, GS2-9 (2024), is scoped to all crystalline and powdered sugars up to 600 ICUMSA units, which is a measurement, not a grade.

Can coconut sugar be ICUMSA 45?

Not as the trade grade. The benchmark white sugar futures contract defines it for white beet, cane crystal or refined sugar, with limits on polarisation and moisture as well as colour (ICE Futures Europe, White Sugar Futures, as read 5 November 2026).

Does ICUMSA define the ICUMSA 45 grade?

No. ICUMSA describes itself as concerned solely with analytical methods for the sugar industry (ICUMSA, About ICUMSA, as read 5 November 2026). The 45 limit is set in sugar trade contracts; the benchmark is ICE’s White Sugar futures contract, which uses an ICUMSA colour measurement.

What should a coconut sugar RFQ specify instead of an ICUMSA grade?

Colour in words, moisture, ash, sucrose and particle size. Our limit for each is in the specification table on this page.

Sources

  1. ICE Futures Europe (Intercontinental Exchange) · White Sugar Futures — contract specifications · industry-body · fetched
  2. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · About ICUMSA · standards-body · fetched
  3. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · Scope of ICUMSA Methods Book · standards-body · fetched
  4. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · ICUMSA Method GS1-7 (2024) · standards-body · fetched
  5. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · ICUMSA Method GS2-9 (2024) · standards-body · fetched
  6. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · ICUMSA Method GS2-10 (2024) · standards-body · fetched
  7. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · ICUMSA Method GS9-8 (2026) · standards-body · fetched
  8. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · Recommendations 2023 · standards-body · fetched
  9. International Commission for Uniform Methods of Sugar Analysis (ICUMSA) · Recommendations 2025 · standards-body · fetched