Authenticity & Adulteration Testing: δ¹³C Isotope Method
Direct answer
How is coconut sugar tested for added cane or corn sugar?
A δ¹³C test measures the ratio of carbon-13 to carbon-12 in a sugar. Coconut sugar comes from a C3 plant; cane and corn sugar come from C4 plants, which carry more carbon-13 (Ždiniaková and de la Calle, European Food Research and Technology, 2020). Added cane or corn sugar pushes the reading up; one study proposes −24.1‰ as the maximum for coconut sugar (Rogers et al., Food Analytical Methods, 2021).
This page sits under what coconut sugar is.
1. The method in one paragraph
The sugar is analysed by isotope-ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS), which reports δ¹³C in parts per thousand (‰). C3 plants read about −27‰ and C4 plants about −12‰ (Louie, Journal of Nutrition, 2026), so cane or corn sugar mixed into coconut sugar moves the result toward the C4 end. The physics, and the full range table, are on C3 vs C4 and why isotopes reveal added sugar.
2. The published evidence
Rogers et al. analysed Indonesian coconut sugar from different local producers over two years (Rogers et al., Food Analytical Methods, 2021). Their findings, as the abstract states them (Rogers et al., Food Analytical Methods, 2021):
| Finding | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Samples | 109, from different local producers, over two years | Rogers et al., 2021 |
| Mean for unadulterated coconut sugar | −25.6‰ ± 0.4‰ | Rogers et al., 2021 |
| Seasonal climate effect | up to ± 0.4‰ | Rogers et al., 2021 |
| Cane sugar added for seeding | up to 5% w/v, raising δ¹³C by up to 0.7‰ | Rogers et al., 2021 |
| Samples where excess C4 sugar was suggested | 31, reading above −24.8‰ | Rogers et al., 2021 |
| Proposed maximum acceptable value | −24.1‰ | Rogers et al., 2021 |
Readings below −26.4‰ may point the other way, to additives such as mangosteen sap used to prevent fermentation of the syrup (Rogers et al., Food Analytical Methods, 2021).
How a buyer commissions an independent δ¹³C test is on how a buyer commissions an independent δ¹³C test.
3. Limits of the method
- Seeding, as the study describes it. Rogers et al. report that up to 5% w/v of cane sugar is often added during production to seed crystallisation, and their proposed −24.1‰ maximum accounts for accepted industry seeding practices (Rogers et al., Food Analytical Methods, 2021).
- A complement for beet. Element profiles measured by energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence (ED-XRF) were proposed as a screening method to authenticate coconut sugar, “an attractive alternative to IRMS” (Ždiniaková and de la Calle, European Food Research and Technology, 2020). The study tested eleven coconut, ten cane and one beetroot sugar sample, so its beet evidence is thin.
Questions about isotope testing
Can a δ¹³C test detect beet sugar in coconut sugar? No. Beet is a C3 plant like coconut, so isotope-ratio mass spectrometry cannot detect beet sugar added to coconut sugar (Ždiniaková and de la Calle, European Food Research and Technology, 2020).
Why can unadulterated coconut sugar read above the −25.6‰ mean? Seasonal climate differences of up to ± 0.4‰, and up to 5% w/v of cane sugar often added to seed crystallisation, which can raise the value by up to 0.7‰. The proposed −24.1‰ maximum allows for both (Rogers et al., Food Analytical Methods, 2021).
Is every lot δ¹³C-tested? No. δ¹³C carbon isotope analysis is one of the tests a buyer can ask for on top of our specification; it is not run on every lot.
Sources
- European Food Research and Technology (Springer), 2020 — authors at the European Commission Joint Research Centre · Feasibility study about the use of element profiles determined by ED-XRF as screening method to authenticate coconut sugar commercially available · peer-reviewed · fetched
- Rogers, Phillips, Yuan et al., Food Analytical Methods 14:1250–1255 (2021), DOI 10.1007/s12161-021-01967-9; AOAC 998.12 analog · peer-reviewed · fetched
- The Journal of Nutrition, 2026; full text via PubMed Central · Carbon Isotope Ratios as Biomarkers for Added Sugar Intake: Fundamental Limitations that Constrain Valid Application · peer-reviewed · fetched